Do you guys remember back a while, when I was on PSC every week, and it was always the same two phones I talked about, the iPhone 4 vs the Samsung Galaxy S? One of the reasons I stepped down was that it was boring even me, let alone the listeners :-)
Well, what do you know, I am now back to that exact same spot :-) Have a read of my original review of the SGS on this very blog
HERE if you forget what I said, things have moved on a little bit since then, and this post is meant as an update to that original piece.
Before I get started, the main thing that has changed for me with the SGS is Darky's ROM. Call him a chef, or a repackager, the result is the same, a fantastic ROM, fast, with all the lag issues solved, rooted out of the box, and built in CWM (ClockworkMod) recovery, all bult right in, and once you are on Darkys, all future upgrades (and boy does he push out upgrades!) are a simple download, click and install, all without losing any data, and all possible on the phone without needing a PC. Without the existence of Darky's, (or other similar ROMS) I would still be a firm and fast iPhone fanboy.
This particular ROM also has a heavy Gingerbread theme, with all the icons in the notifications bar, and the much better Gingerbread keyboard, in fact, there is very little missing from GB here, which after all is just FroYo with some go faster stripes! It also features various Lockscreens, my favorite is the stock Android one, swipe one way to unlock, and the other to set the sound on or off.
This particular SGS I have now is only a few weeks old, and according to my Kindle logs, it is my 5th SGS to date, although I can only recall 4 :-). I got it from O2, at £329 plus a £10 mandatory top up, and I managed to get an unlock for free as an O2 contract customer I simply filled the online unlocking form in, and the code was supplied FOC. A good friend of mine was able to pick one of these up from CEX recently for as little as £235, a real bargain if ever there was one. I guess this phone will soon be discontinued, so if you want one, get one now.
I read today, that Samsung have sold 10 million of the SGS series phones, these are of course renamed in the US as Captivate, Vibrant, Fascinate and Epic 4G. Most of those are not as good as our SGS available in the UK, you wanna know why?
Do you?
Well, its the iPhone button. Yes, I keep banging on and on about it, but the design, clearly a rip off of the iPhone 3GS, features a physical button slap bang in the middle of the phone at the bottom, much the same as every iPhone. You want to check the time, give it a quick press, no hunting on top or the side of the phone for the power button. I fear we may never see another Android phone with this feature, so much so I am thinking of buying another SGS and storing it ready for when this one wears out. Seriously. It just makes so much damn difference to using the phone, and I know a lot of people will laugh at me for this, as they associate the button with iOS, and hence do not give it the time of day. In fact, I have read about Android fanboys hating on the SGS just because it copied an iPhone feature.....madness. The other thing this phone allows, thanks to this button is simple screenshots, another welcome copy from the iPhone.
There is another button that I really miss when I use the iPhone these days, the "back" button. As I hold my phone mainly in my right hand, the SGS one is perfectly placed, and sometimes, on my iPhone 4 I find myself pressing the glass to the right of my home button before feeing completely stupid!
But it is not just the button(s) that has me loving this phone at the moment, the screen is simply lovely, so much nicer than any other TFT or AMOLED I have used, and yes, better even that the iPhone 4 screen.
The speaker allows me to listen to podcasts without being in pain, as all HTC owners are, and just lately some slight shifts in my use are starting to happen, for example, I now much prefer Doggcatcher on the SGS to Podcaster on iOS. For my Audible book listening, the Android app in the UK is fully featured, where as the iPhone app is still only fully usable with US accounts, although there is a clunky workaround for the UK.
Other touches, unique to the SGS, such as the Wi-Fi, BT, GPS, Silent and Rotation butons being built into the notification drop down makes using the phone that little bit easier, more natural somehow. I have also been impressed lately with voice to text, something of a gimmick in my mind, but if you use short sentences, and do two or three for a text, it does a pretty sound job of getting close enough, and with the Gingerbread version of the editing method being built into this ROM, it is now as easy as doing it on the iPhone.
I recently bought a Sony MEX-3800U headunit for my Clio, and one for Jackie's Scenic, the great thing about them is they just replace the standard radio, all wiring is the same and fitting takes a few mins. For £112 on Amazon, they are a true bargain, and work really, really well with the iPhone 4. Once used, every time you get into the car, assuming you leave BT on of course, the two bond together, and all phone calls and phone audio get sent via the car speakers. Great for podcasts, or music, or phone calls, which mute the radio/podcast/music and restart after the call. Now, with my last SGS and the SGT, this was not working, with BT dropping out every few seconds, only on audio mind, phone calls always work.
On top of this, only the iPhone would auto reconnect with the unit, and the Android devices had to be manually connected by going to settings and clicking on the relevant item. Somehow, with this latest ROM, the thing now just works, auto reconnects, without me touching anything, and the icing on the cake is that there is no longer any audio dropout, it works 100% now. I think the SGS at this point has as much talent developing for it as any other Android phone, and the physical button, screen, speaker, and lower price makes it one of the best, if not the best Android phone available today.
The only area where the SGS could be improved is to make a version with a camera flash, and get the build quality up to Nexus S level, put the power socket on the bottom. I don't suppose they will though. Rather they will likely just carry on the arms race, with ever more powerful CPUs, probably with correspondingly less battery life, and anonymous slabs of glass with ever changing button positions below the screen. These ROMs prove to me that we really don't need much more than a 1Ghz CPU in a phone.
So, all in all, I can not recall the last time I enjoyed a phone so much. Wait, yes, I can, it was the iPhone 3GS.
Please comment on twitter, I am @kevwright, and do follow @darkyy92
Kev